Computer & Communication Industry Association
PublishedNovember 18, 2010

CCIA’s Black Tells Senate, “Internet Censorship Is A Trade Barrier”

Computer & Communications Industry Association President & CEO Ed Black is scheduled to testify Thursday at a Senate Finance subcommittee hearing, “International Trade in the Digital Economy.” The issue of Internet censorship and filtering has received more attention from the State Department and USTR during the Obama administration.

Black has been an advocate on international free speech and censorship issues for decades and continues to serve on the State Department’s Advisory Committee on International Communication and Information Policy.

Black will tell the committee that CCIA members report 40 countries engage in broad, widespread Internet censorship. Whether this is to block information for political reasons or to protect domestic firms from competition, the net impact is that US companies are facing barriers to foreign markets.

Black says information discrimination represents a classic “non-tariff trade barrier” and recommends U.S. officials enforce existing laws and ensure new international agreements better protect the digital economy by clearly banning Internet filtering, censorship and secondary liability.

In his testimony, Black will offer details on which countries are creating barriers along with examples of nations enacting policies that keep US firms from doing business and favor incumbent domestic tech companies. The examples range from intentionally redirecting Internet traffic from foreign sites to domestic sites, to using filtering technology that causes foreign-based services to be degraded for domestic users. There is also a ripple effect beyond tech companies to the advertisers, who are the direct revenue source for many Internet services.

The following quotes can be attributed to CCIA President & CEO Ed Black’s testimony:

“The free expression and free flow of ideas is a necessary condition for successful governance under democratic principles. Attempts to control the citizenry’s access to information must be relegated to the dustbin of history. Government restrictions on content and services are more worthy of “1984” than 2010.

“When governments treat foreign firms differently, they are erecting to market entry that would not otherwise exist, creating advantages for domestic firms and disadvantages for foreign competitors. Such advantages range from intentionally redirecting Internet traffic from foreign sites to domestic sites, to using filtering technology that causes foreign-based services to be degraded for domestic users. These practices also affect advertisers, who are the direct revenue source for many Internet services.

“Restrictions on access to information will reduce demand for computing devices and consumer communications devices, markets in which U.S. businesses have strong positions and strong brands. Information discrimination thus impairs many industries at the heart of the U.S. information technology sector.

“Unreasonable liability rules in other countries are effectively acting as market barriers. Since the early days of the Internet, Congress has recognized that holding Internet and e-commerce businesses liable for the wrongful conduct of their users would jeopardize the growth of this vital industry and place unreasonable burdens on these companies. We next to export language like the safe harbors provision in the Digital Millennium Copyright act as well as another provision in the Communications Decency Act that that allows Internet companies to combat undesirable or illegal content without fear of liability.

“We must also discourage attempts to deputize online intermediaries into law enforcement. If the United States cannot maintain a free and open Internet, we cannot expect that any other nation will do so. Proposals to require Internet communication services to build in back doors for government eavesdropping would create vulnerabilities in secure communications systems, making it easier for governments across the globe to further tamp down on the free flow of information, censor content, and block disfavored services.”

News

CCIA Raises Constitutional and Privacy Concerns with Kansas App Store Age Verification Proposals

Washington – The Computer & Communications Industry Association will testify today before the Kansas Legislature’s Special Committee on Protecting Children from Online Harm. CCIA will express ...
reading-tablet
  • Press Releases
  • Online Safety
News

CCIA Report Highlights Expanding State Privacy Regulation

Washington – The Computer & Communications Industry Association today released its 2026 State Privacy Landscape Report. This year, four states enacted comprehensive consumer privacy laws, while ...
reading-tablet
  • Press Releases
  • Privacy
News

New CCIA Study Finds Generative AI Market Remains Dynamic and Competitive

Washington - Generative AI prices are plunging, market leaders keep getting overtaken, and startups are capturing most new application revenue, as shown in a new report from RBB Economics prepared for...
reading-tablet
  • Press Releases
  • Competition
News

Digital Fairness Act Overlaps With Existing EU Rules Despite Commission’s Recent Pledge to Cut Red Tape

Brussels, BELGIUM – The European Commission today proposed its Digital Fairness Act (DFA), aiming to strengthen online consumer protection. While the planned EU-wide regulation might help reduce div...
reading-tablet
  • Press Releases
    Digital Economy